Skip to content

5 Most Common Mistakes Innovators Make When Submitting To Innovation Competitions? S12 Ep29

Phil McKinney
Phil McKinney
1 min read
5 Most Common Mistakes Innovators Make When Submitting To Innovation Competitions? S12 Ep29

Winning innovation competitions or innovation awards can be a major achievement and proof of you and your teams ability to innovate. Which innovation competitions or awards should you submit to? Are there any downsides to submitting and winning a competiton or an award?

In this weeks show, we discuss the structures and thinking behind innovation competitions and innovations awards and I share the 5 most common mistakes I've experienced as a judge.

Innovation Awards

  • A special guest, Tom Kuczmarski, shared an update on the Chicago Innovation Awards.
  • This award is now in its 15th year.
  • Of the ~200 awards given in the past, 100% of the companies and organizations are still around.
  • This year they will give out 10 awards including some new ones such as; Social Innovation, Peoples Choice Awards and Neighborhood Awards.
  • Criteria they use to select the winner of the Chicago Innovation Award?
    • What was the customer need the innovation addressed?
    • What was the impact from the innovation?
    • Was their a competitive response? (indication of impact since others attempt to copy)
    • Did the innovation create a new category?

Innovation Competitions

  • What are the different type of innovation competitions?
    • Solution search like Idea Connection
    • Broad new ideas
    • Narrow/focused new ideas
  • Approaches to applying to a competition
    • Forward approach: Read the competition and solve for the ask proposed in competition material
    • Backward approach: Take an idea you already have and find a competition where it can be applied

5 Most Common Mistakes

  1. Not doing sufficient research on the space to fully understand the problem/ask beyond what was presented in the competition material.
  2. Not fully reading/understand the ask. Make sure you don't inject assumptions and bias into crafting your solution to a misunderstood ask.
  3. Not following the guidelines on submissions. Understand what/how/format of the submission.
  4. Submitting an weak/shallow submission. Apply some deep thinking (go beyond the obvious) and create a killer presentation/pitch. Don't short change it.
  5. Not understanding the IP (intellectual property) rules for the competition.
Studio SessionsPast ShowsChicago Innovation AwardsIdea Connectioninnovation awardsinnovation competitionsTom Kuczmarski

Phil McKinney Twitter

Phil McKinney is an innovator, podcaster, author, and speaker. He is the retired CTO of HP. Phil's book, Beyond The Obvious, shares his expertise and lessons learned on innovation and creativity.

Comments


Related Posts

The Innovation Metric Bill Hewlett and Dave Packard Used

HP used this R&D benchmark for decades and still managed to forget it. Most companies never found it.

Image of Bill Hewlett and David Packard sharing a secret

The R&D Metric Mark Hurd and HP Got Wrong

How one flawed benchmark drove years of R&D decisions and quietly drained HP's innovation pipeline.

The R&D Metric Mark Hurd and HP Got Wrong

How To Think for Yourself When Everyone Disagrees With You

Why your brain treats disagreement like danger, and a simple two-minute technique to protect your thinking.

How To Think for Yourself When Everyone Disagrees With You