Skip to content

Managing the Fuzzy Front End Of The Innovation Funnel S12 Ep31

Phil McKinney
Phil McKinney
— 2 min read
The Innovators Studio podcast cover art: Managing the Fuzzy Front End Of The Innovation Funnel S12 Ep31

Managing the fuzzy front end of the innovation funnel can be daunting especially when management has high expectations from the innovation efforts.

This weeks show focused on answering a question emailed in by a listener. The question focused on the challenges of creating an innovation process for a team within a large organization and dealing with the "fuzzy front end".

The fuzzy front end is what some people call "phase 0" of the innovation effort. This front end of innovation is non-linear and can be chaotic and frustrating. It doesn't have to be if you apply a proven approach to getting this early stage innovation work under control.

[shareable]When creating new innovation processes and teams, the first step is managing management. [/shareable]

Managing Management

When creating new innovation processes and teams, the first step is managing management. They've tasked you with creating the team and process that will generate great outcomes. So how do you manage management?

  • Manage expectations. Get agreement on the final deliverables such as "2 products per year"
  • Keep management focused on the deliverables and don't let them in the "tent" to see the messiness of innovation
  • Keep your ideas quiet. Do NOT share them until they are ready
  • You control the reveal of your innovation teams output.

If you don't do the above, you run of the risk of trying management's patience and run afoul of the "Rule of 18"

Three Steps To Manage The Fuzzy Front End

Here are the three (3) steps to get control of the chaotic things going on when trying to get started in your innovation process.

Step 1:  Create Your Innovation Funnel

  • Establish your funnel by defining how many stages/gates it will have. I use four (4).
  • Define the deliverable goal. While CTO at HP, my goal was two (2) fundamentally new products each year.
  • Back into the numbers of each of the earlier gates assuming a 50% kill rate in each phase.
  • In my case, my funnel look like the following:
    • New Products = 2 projects
    • Limiated lauch/lighthouse trial = 5 projects
    • Customer Validation = 10 projects
    • Market Validation =20 projects
  • This translates to a 10% success rate from the first gate to launch.

Step 2: Fill Your Innovation Funnel

  • Fill the funnel using Focus, Ideation and Ranking (three of the four steps in FIRE)
  • Test, experiment and be willing to kill ideas.
  • Even when you don't feel like you're making progress, you are. Perseverance.
  • Understand the impact of long development cycles on filling your innovation funnel.
  • Don't be afraid to ask for time to "prime the funnel". I got two (2) years when I started the funnel at HP.

Step 3: Manage Your Innovation Funnel

  • Don't neglect managing the funnel. Be deliberate.
  • Move things forward. Don't let them just hang around.
  • Be willing to pause an idea if the timing is not right.
  • Don't be afraid to kill an idea. Make the tough call.

Show Bonus: A FREE download of my Innovation Funnel and a sample Stage Gate model

Other Resources:

Past ShowsStudio Sessionsfunnelfuzzy front endfuzzy front end of innovationInnovationInnovation Funnelmanaging management

Phil McKinney Twitter

Phil McKinney is an innovator, podcaster, author, and speaker. He is the retired CTO of HP. Phil's book, Beyond The Obvious, shares his expertise and lessons learned on innovation and creativity.


Related Posts

How To Build Innovation Teams (My Playbook From HP and CableLabs)

How to build innovation teams, from the playbook I used at HP and CableLabs: culture before hiring, the right roles, the Idea Fund, and the right metrics

Image of how to build innovation teams. Portions are generated by AI.

How To Improve Your Analytical Thinking Skills

Critical thinking judges a claim. Analytical thinking works the problem: break it apart, find what is really driving it, and test your read before acting.

How To Improve Your Analytical Thinking Skills

Never Forget: 25 Years Remembering Charles Falkenberg and His Family

First written September 11, 2008. Updated for the 25th anniversary, September 11, 2026.

Charles Falkenberg and his famly