Skip to content

What is surprisingly inconvenient about my product

Phil McKinney
Phil McKinney
3 min read
What is surprisingly inconvenient about my product

What is surprisingly inconvenient about my product?

The designers and engineers who work at HP face many challenges in getting their ideas signed off on.
It’s a long process from an idea to a finished prototype.
Before any product can hit the market, it faces one final test.
I take the prototype home, give it to my wife, and say, “Tell me what you think.”

Now, my wife is an extremely smart and focused individual, but she is emphatically not a techie.
She doesn’t care how a gadget works; she just wants it to work.

Her lack of specialized knowledge has been hugely valuable to me over the years.
If I test a new product, I can troubleshoot it almost without thinking.
I might not even notice a glitch that could cause major hassles for an end consumer because the fix is second-nature to me.
On the other hand, if my wife can’t get a product to work, the first thing she does is call me up and yell at me, which is a great incentive to get our products as flawless as possible.

Back in 2007, she was relocating her stained-glass studio to California from our former home on the East Coast.
She was a little nervous about the drive.
Luckily, I had just been given the first working model for the latest GPS device that HP was about to go into production on .
I gave her a quick lesson, and off she went.
Three days later she calls me from the road, almost speechless with rage.
The GPS looked great and had the lasted hardware features anyone could want.
What it didn’t have was accurate maps.
Every time my wife searched for rest stops, it came up empty.

When she finally made it out west, she met me for lunch at the HP cafeteria.
The head of our division that developed the product came up and asked her what she thought.
Her response?

“Well, it was clearly designed by a guy; I stopped at every crummy gas-station bathroom between here and Kentucky!”

The GPS was super-fast, looked great, but had completely missed the mark on why people buy GPS devices, which is based almost purely the quality of the maps and the points of interests along the way.
Great hardware can’t compensate for faulty software.

The GPS device failed the wife test, and it had failed my test too.
It was sent back to the drawing board.

There are two ways to uncover these kinds of potential annoyances in your new or existing products.
One is to observe your customers and see what they are doing with your product and what their experience with it is.
The other is, use the product yourself.
Either way, you need to be fanatical about constantly improving the product and getting rid of the problems you uncover.
Keep in mind that I’ve observed major differences between how men and women handle these issues.
Guys have ego wrapped up in their new devices; they won’t let the gadget win.
A woman will give it three chances; if she tries to use a new product three times and it doesn’t work, she’ll take it back to the store because she doesn’t have any interest in fighting with the product and winning.
Men are much more likely to keep tinkering with the device and, if all else fails, stick it in the garage and forget about it.
If it doesn’t work for a woman, she’ll let you know, and you’ll have a returned product on your store shelves.
This is one of the reasons I rely so heavily on the wife test; my wife is a zero-tolerance consumer.
If you don’t have a zero-tolerance consumer, you need to find one and embrace them.
Have them test your products and give you the unvarnished truth about your products’ real usefulness and value.

That way – you can answer the question ---

What is surprisingly inconvenient about my product?

But don’t stop there .. ask yourself ..

[Sparking Points]

How do you uncover what customers perceive to be inconvenient about your product?

Are you aware of the inconveniences?

Do you use your own product or service?

What’s your version of the wife test?

Go beyond the obvious by ignoring your own likes and dislikes about any given product. You are NOT the best gauge of your customer. Get up – and go talk to them.


Phil McKinney Twitter

Phil McKinney is an innovator, podcaster, author, and speaker. He is the retired CTO of HP. Phil's book, Beyond The Obvious, shares his expertise and lessons learned on innovation and creativity.


Related Posts

Members Public

The Hidden Price of Tomorrow's Innovations

In the quest for a tech utopia, what shadows lurk behind innovation's glow? What are the untold costs and narratives masked in progress? We need to take a balanced perspective on technological utopianism so that we have a future that is not just bright but also truly beneficial for all.

The Hidden Price of Tomorrow's Innovations
Members Public

Is Boredom the Silent Muse?

Unlock creativity through boredom? Our fast-paced lives fear silence, but stillness may be the key to focus and innovation. What should you do? Embrace boredom, reclaim your attention, and unlock your full potential.

A man walkin the woods deep in thought
Members Public

The Myth of Scarcity: The Endless Supply of Ideas

It's time to shift our mindset from win/lose to win/win. The unlimited potential of ideas and innovation allows us all to succeed without taking away from others. The limit to our success is the limitation of our imagination.

The Myth of Scarcity: The Endless Supply of Ideas